revolutionary tools.  groundbreaking articles.  proven results.

On the Relationship Between Scouting and Advanced Stats (Part I)


Below I’ve embedded a tweet from last night where I jokingly pointed out a problem that I think exists with the idea that tape grinding is the highest form of football evaluation.  Just to be clear, I wasn’t really trying to bust Steve’s chops that much as he’s an all around good dude and I think that we would probably agree on a bunch of the big picture issues related to eval (and I’ll get there before this piece is done.. and before you even read the rest of this piece you should follow Steve on Twitter).  But it was an interesting thing to think about anyway, so let’s break this down.


The primary problem that I think the tape grinding crew has when it comes to eval is that eventually we’re going to need a way to settle the basic question as to which football players are good, and which football players are bad, and how are we going to do that?  We could use our individual opinions about players, that’s one way to skin the cat.  I say Brandon Lloyd sucks, I’ve seen some tape grinders say he’s good.  How do we decide who’s right (I mean other than simply dismissing my opinion because it came from a spreadsheet)?  Let’s forget about that issue for a minute.  Let’s say we disagree about which teams are good and bad… except that’s not likely to happen is it?  Why?  We have win/loss records to settle the dispute.  And while win/loss records are subject to all sorts of issues with variance (turnovers, wins in close games, etc), they are generally a good indication of who is good and who isn’t right?  But that creates a problem because now we’ve settled the issue not by watching tape, or through a subjective assessment.  We have a pretty concrete way to end the argument over which teams are good and which teams are bad.  And if we return for a minute to the issue of Brandon Lloyd, how long do you think it would take before the straw-man tape grinder that I’ve created would offer Lloyd’s 2010 statistically good season in defense of his opinion?  It would happen pretty quickly right?  And there’s the issue for the tape grinders.  Eventually we’re going to be talking about some kind of objective measure, and it will probably be a simple counting stat like yards or touchdowns.

Before I piss anyone off any more than I already have, let me offer that in some sense grinding tape is just a reaction to the very real problem which is that the box score does not contain enough data.  On that point, I think I speak for all numbers focused watchers of football when I say that we would all love to have more data rather than less.  So all of the things that are showing up in tape sessions – like whether a QB throws from his back foot, or whether a WR rounds off his routes – we’d love to see numbers on all of that stuff.  As I’ve said to Eric Stoner on twitter before, I think that the advanced stats crowd would find a lot of common ground with the tape grinding crowd if we could all just figure out how to record what’s being watched.  In other words “All of that is great.  Now let’s write it down.”  Because in the end, all the advanced stat crowd wants is the ability to backtest the effectiveness of a process/model.

The need to backtest the effectiveness of your process is central to the idea that I’ll talk about tomorrow in Part II of this series, which is the notion that over time your evaluations should improve.  Today I just wanted to establish that at least on a very important part of the player evaluation discussion, it’s likely that in the end we’ll be talking about numbers.  So if numbers will be a key part of the end of the discussion, it seems odd to dismiss their usefulness at the start of the discussion.

recent and related...

in case you missed it...

Bracket Busting: For All The Marbles

High-stakes writers Monty Phan and John Lapinski chronicle their entry in the FFPC Super Bracket contest. The Super Bracket regular season runs for just 11 weeks, and the league is far from decided. After a solid win last week, we’re right back in the thick of it. Here are the

Read More

Week 11 Yahoo! DFS Picks

Identifying my Week 11 NFL DFS picks was easier than it’s ever been thanks to the continued work of our apps development team. The NFL Stat Explorer, the DFS Lineup Optimizer, and our world-famous Game Splits App are three windows I never close on my screen. Let’s build a plan

Read More

Week 11 Primetime Slate DFS Breakdown

Who are the best plays for the Week 11 DFS primetime slate on DraftKings and FanDuel? Tyler Loechner runs through notes on the primetime short slate featuring SNF/MNF games.1 DSF Week 11 Primetime Slate DFS Week 11 Primetime Slate theory thoughts: The two games on this slate are dramatically different

Read More

High Staked: Hello Darkness, My Old Friend

Veteran high stakes fantasy football player Monty Phan chronicles his season. Welcome to Week 11 in FFPC high stakes, where, once again, we’re reminded that there’s a big difference between what we think should happen and what actually occurs. For a lot of teams, it’s – mercifully – the final

Read More

Week 12 Waiver Wire Advice: Top Targets At Each Position

Looking for Week 12 waiver wire advice for fantasy football? You’ve come to the right place. We’ll give you some of the top targets at each position so that when you submit a waiver claim, you do it with confidence. This article will run through the top players available in

Read More

Sign-up today for our free Premium Email subscription!

© 2019 RotoViz. All rights Reserved.