revolutionary tools.  groundbreaking articles.  proven results.

E.J. Manuel – More JaMarcus Russell, or Ben Roethlisberger?

EJ Manuel Miami v Florida State xwlWoVZR6qql

Similarity scores are good for some things and then don’t shed any light at all on other things.  For instance, similarity scores are generally good at splitting players up based on dimensions.  Is the quarterback accurate?  Is he only accurate because he’s checking down all day?  What size of a player is he similar to?  Those are the questions that similarity scores are good at answering.  Similarity scores don’t shed any light on things like work ethic, or intelligence.  We don’t have any visibility on issues like that.  The reason this matters as it relates to Manuel is because some of his comps that failed, failed because they reportedly didn’t have the necessary work ethic to make it in the NFL.

E.J. Manuel is similar to a number of really high upside quarterbacks that haven’t always panned out.  Among the names on the list are JaMarcus Russell and Nate Davis, two of the more gifted QB prospects of the last decade in terms of physical ability.  In fact, almost all of the guys on Manuel’s comps list below are pretty gifted physically, while only one guy has really put together a successful NFL career (Roethlisberger… in case you weren’t sure).  The jury is still out on Matt Stafford and Josh Freeman probably has one more season before he’s officially a wash out in the NFL, but you can probably see what I’m getting at here.  Manuel is similar to guys who, if they failed, didn’t fail for lack of physical ability.  So while looking at Manuel’s comps might help us place him from a draft value standpoint, it doesn’t give us any visibility really into whether he’ll make it as a pro.  I think I’ll probably own the Geno/Manuel combo in some leagues this year, hoping that one pays off with some rushing yards, but as a real life QB prospect, he seems like maybe a coin flip.

Let’s say for the sake of argument that someone was willing to offer you JaMarcus Russell but with Kobe Bryant’s work ethic.  You would want that guy to be your franchise QB right?  I have no idea what Manuel’s work ethic is.  My only point is that being similar to Russell doesn’t have to be a bad thing.  He might be dissimilar on something that box score stats don’t tell us and that might make all the difference.

I always go through the implications of the similarity measures, so for Manuel, he’s similar to other big QBs, who averaged excellent yards/attempt, had generally high CMP % and also mixed in at least a little running of the football.  All of Manuel’s comps were first round picks as well, with the exception of Nate Davis, whose name I left on the list because he was actually the closest comp.

NAME HT WT TM Season G Cmp% PYDS TD INT YA RYDS Career G Career Yds Career TD/INT
E.J. Manuel 77.00 237.00 Florida State 2012 14.00 0.68 242.64 1.64 0.71 8.78 22.14 40.00 7,741.00 1.68
NAME HT WT TM Season G Cmp% PYDS TD INT YA RYDS Career G Career Yds Career TD/INT
Nate Davis 74.00 226.00 Ball State 2008 14.00 0.64 256.50 1.86 0.57 8.96 22.29 39.00 9,233.00 3.36
Matthew Stafford 74.00 225.00 Georgia 2008 13.00 0.61 266.08 1.92 0.77 9.03 3.08 39.00 7,731.00 1.55
Jason Campbell 77.00 230.00 Auburn 2004 13.00 0.70 207.69 1.54 0.54 10.00 2.31 46.00 7,299.00 1.88
Josh Freeman 78.00 248.00 Kansas State 2008 12.00 0.59 245.42 1.67 0.67 7.71 33.67 35.00 8,078.00 1.29
Ben Roethlisberger 77.00 241.00 Miami (OH) 2003 14.00 0.69 320.43 2.64 0.71 9.06 7.93 38.00 10,829.00 2.47
JaMarcus Russell 78.00 265.00 Louisiana State 2006 13.00 0.68 240.69 2.15 0.62 9.15 10.92 35.00 6,625.00 2.48

recent and related...

in case you missed it...

Bracket Busting: For All The Marbles

High-stakes writers Monty Phan and John Lapinski chronicle their entry in the FFPC Super Bracket contest. The Super Bracket regular season runs for just 11 weeks, and the league is far from decided. After a solid win last week, we’re right back in the thick of it. Here are the

Read More

Week 11 Yahoo! DFS Picks

Identifying my Week 11 NFL DFS picks was easier than it’s ever been thanks to the continued work of our apps development team. The NFL Stat Explorer, the DFS Lineup Optimizer, and our world-famous Game Splits App are three windows I never close on my screen. Let’s build a plan

Read More

Week 11 Primetime Slate DFS Breakdown

Who are the best plays for the Week 11 DFS primetime slate on DraftKings and FanDuel? Tyler Loechner runs through notes on the primetime short slate featuring SNF/MNF games.1 DSF Week 11 Primetime Slate DFS Week 11 Primetime Slate theory thoughts: The two games on this slate are dramatically different

Read More

High Staked: Hello Darkness, My Old Friend

Veteran high stakes fantasy football player Monty Phan chronicles his season. Welcome to Week 11 in FFPC high stakes, where, once again, we’re reminded that there’s a big difference between what we think should happen and what actually occurs. For a lot of teams, it’s – mercifully – the final

Read More

Week 12 Waiver Wire Advice: Top Targets At Each Position

Looking for Week 12 waiver wire advice for fantasy football? You’ve come to the right place. We’ll give you some of the top targets at each position so that when you submit a waiver claim, you do it with confidence. This article will run through the top players available in

Read More

Sign-up today for our free Premium Email subscription!

© 2019 RotoViz. All rights Reserved.