revolutionary tools.  groundbreaking articles.  proven results.

Antonio Callaway is the Next…? The Exciting Rookie Comps for the Browns WR

Browns wide receiver Antonio Callaway is next up as we take a look at the most comparable players for the 11 best rookie WRs from the 2018 class.

As a fourth-round draft pick playing on a poor team embroiled in coaching and QB turmoil, Callaway’s emergence into fantasy relevance may be the most intriguing narrative among all rookie WRs.

He burst onto the scene in just his second game, posting 81 yards and a TD on four targets against the Saints. The wild thing about Callaway is that while his fourth-place finish in rookie WR points is impressive, it could have been so much more.

  • His 1,100 air yards were second among all rookies behind Courtland Sutton and ranked 30th among all WRs
  • His 20 percent market share of air yards was second among rookies
  • His 136.2 expected receiving points (reEP) were also second among rookie WRs, behind Calvin Ridley

The Browns looked to the rookie early, often, and deep. If it weren’t for his sub-par efficiency, he could have challenged Ridley for the top rookie in raw points.

Calvin Ridley 64 92 821 10 150.5 55.6 208.8
D.J. Moore 55 82 788 2 135.1 10.7 160.2
Courtland Sutton 42 84 704 4 136.1 0.3 136.3
Antonio Callaway 43 81 586 5 136.2 -4.6 132.3
Christian Kirk 43 68 590 3 102.7 17.3 123.5
Anthony Miller 33 54 423 7 93.2 24.1 120.3
Marquez Valdes-Scantling 38 72 581 2 113.2 -5.1 111
Dante Pettis 27 45 467 5 75.2 28.5 103.5
Tre’Quan Smith 28 44 427 5 74.2 26.5 100.7
Robert Foster 26 44 522 3 71.5 24.7 96.2



Using inputs of target volume, production, efficiency, age, weight, and draft position, I used the RotoViz Screener to come up with the most similar rookie seasons to Callaway’s since 2000.

I was expecting to see a decent list of comparables for Callaway, but this is heady company indeed. His tender age combined with elite opportunity as a rookie lands him among a group that, at worst, doesn’t feature a single bust, and at best, is borderline elite.

Perhaps I shouldn’t be so surprised. After all, he did register the second-highest Phenom Index in the class, behind only DJ Moore. And you know we love us some young WRs here at RotoViz.

Allen Robinson is the most exciting name on the list, and the two had similar rookie seasons, although the former Jaguar has 20 pounds on Callaway, and they don’t quite have the same style of games.

I love the Chris Godwin comp. Both men slid too far in the NFL Draft, then made everyone look silly by making an immediate impact on the field and fantasy rosters.

What Did They Do in Year 2?

Every one of these WRs either took a step forward as a sophomore or went on to much bigger things in their careers.

Robinson is the gold standard — he was the overall WR6 as a sophomore with an incredible 1,408 yards.
Godwin is currently one of the hottest blue-chip prospects in dynasty football. In games without DeSean Jackson, he was on pace to be the overall WR19, and Jackson is now officially gone.

Antonio Bryant didn’t flash in year two, but he went on to an excellent career, twice hitting 1,000 yards and averaging 812 yards over his seven seasons.

Robert Woods needed to escape Buffalo to find his form. He took a while to reach his potential, but he’s coming off a 1,219-yard, WR11 season.

Tyler Boyd similarly struggled as a sophomore before exploding in year three with 1,029 yards and seven TDs.


In a vacuum, Callaway’s projects to be a fantasy difference maker in the NFL, and it’s more likely than not that he hits the 1,000-yard mark at some point.

The worry is that the Browns add a WR in the draft or free agency, cutting into his opportunity. He also comes with some off-field concerns, but if all that that allows you to acquire him at a discount, all the better.

As we see from his comps, Callaway may require some patience, but there is nothing but upside here.

Check out the top comparables for the rest of the 2018 rookie WR class:
11. Michael Gallup
10. Robert Foster
9. Tre’Quan Smith
8. Dante Pettis
7. Marquez Valdes-Scantling
6. Anthony Miller
5. Christian Kirk

recent and related

In case you missed it

Rapid Reaction: Third Round Opportunity Outlook

  What a crazy ride Day 2 of the draft was. I’m exhausted from excitement. The landing spots attained by the high end skill position players in this class is going to make this draft class a force for years to come. The third round will have a more abbreviated

Read More

2019 Dynasty Rookie Rankings and Tiers: Post-NFL Draft Edition

  Post-NFL Draft 2019 Dynasty fantasy football rookie rankings are here! Which rookies hit the trio of strong profile, early draft position, and great NFL landing spot? The RotoViz team has already adjusted their outlook on which players are the best dynasty investments. I’ve drawn in the tiers based on

Read More

Box Score Scout: 2019 NFL Draft First-Round Player Comparisons

  February to April is ruled by Draft Twitter. Countless hot takes, I’m right/you’re wrong, and no middle ground. As always, there were plenty of surprising draft picks, which certainly affects fantasy football value. While the media oftentimes uses the best case scenario for player comparisons, the RotoViz Box Score

Read More

3 Rookie WRs I’m Targeting in Dynasty Leagues After the NFL Draft

  With the NFL Draft in the books, it’s time to turn our attention to dynasty league rookie drafts. Some wide receivers landed in perfect situations while others fell further than expected. With receivers like Hakeem Butler and Kelvin Harmon slipping to Day 3, rookie draft position is in flux. However, some

Read More

Sign-up today for our free Premium Email subscription!

© 2019 RotoViz. All rights Reserved.