revolutionary tools.  groundbreaking articles.  proven results.

2019’s WR Phenom Index Scores and the Buccaneers Deep Sleeper Who Tops Them All

We’re rolling along in our deep sleeper series, and by now you know the drill — these are guys who have something in their profile that gives us hope, despite what their depressed ADP is telling us.

Something a little different for this one, as we’re getting our first look at this year’s wide receiver Phenom Index numbers, a Jon Moore metric which measures age-adjusted production.

And our Buccaneers deep sleeper comes in No. 1 in the 2019 class. Before we tell you who it is, here’s a look at the rest of this year’s dark horses so far:


New England Patriots | New York Jets | Miami Dolphins


Houston Texans | Indianapolis Colts | Jacksonville Jaguars | Tennessee Titans


Cincinnati Bengals | Pittsburgh Steelers | Baltimore Ravens | Cleveland Browns


Los Angeles Chargers | Denver Broncos | Kansas City Chiefs


Dallas Cowboys | Philadelphia Eagles | Washington


Detroit Lions | Minnesota Vikings

NFC South

New Orleans Saints | Atlanta Falcons

Scotty Miller, WR

Pat Kerrane got the Scotty Miller hype train going back in May, just in time for me to snap up Miller in the final rounds of a dynasty rookie draft.

The rest of us at RotoViz were sleeping while Kerrane was tabulating this year’s Phenom Index scores and realizing that the 208th overall pick from this draft is perhaps the most prodigious receiver of them all.

2019 Phenom Index Scores

Before we jump into this year’s Phenom Index (PI), a quick refresher on why PI matters from Jon Moore, who created the metric.

The Phenom Index is calculated by looking at player’s age and their final season market share of receiving yards and bolting them together using z-scores. Typically, I like to think about this as a filter for finding young, talented players who could emerge to be among the game’s best within three seasons.

Pat Kerrane has calculated not only this year’s PI scores but also whether or not the player was an early declare. Blair Andrews recently found that WRs who declare early average more than 200 fantasy points over their first two seasons.

PlayerNFL TeamRoundDraft PickSchoolDOBFY MSYMSY ZAgeAge ZPhenom IndexEarly Declare
Scott MillerTAM6208Bowling Green7/31/1997441.721.42-1.132.87No
N'Keal HarryNWE132Arizona St.12/17/1997381.221.04-1.552.73Yes
Andy IsabellaARI262Massachusetts11/18/9647222.12-0.342.38No
Kelvin HarmonWAS6206NC St.12/16/1997300.421.04-1.551.96Yes
Marquise BrownBAL125Oklahoma6/4/1997330.721.57-0.951.65Yes
A.J. BrownTEN251Mississippi6/30/97320.621.5-1.031.63Yes
Hakeem ButlerARI4103Iowa St.5/16/96421.622.630.231.33Yes
D.K. MetcalfSEA264Mississippi12/14/9723-0.321.05-1.541.28Yes
JJ Arcega-WhitesidePHI257Stanford12/31/96330.722-0.481.17No
KeeSean JohnsonARI6174Fresno St.10/9/96350.922.23-0.221.11No
Mecole HardmanKAN256Georgia3/12/9817-0.820.8-1.810.98Yes
Dillon MitchellMIN7239Oregon5/16/9636122.630.230.76Yes
Parris CampbellIND259Ohio St.7/16/9721-0.521.46-1.080.63Yes
Olabisi JohnsonMIN7247Colorado St.3/17/9723-0.321.79-0.710.45No
Marcus GreenATL6203La-Monroe8/13/1996280.222.38-0.050.26No
Miles BoykinBAL393Notre Dame10/12/9626022.22-0.230.26Yes
Diontae JohnsonPIT366Toledo7/5/9626022.490.07-0.05Yes
Jalen HurdSFO367Baylor1/23/1996280.222.940.58-0.36No
Travis FulghamDET6184Old Dominion9/13/95300.423.30.98-0.57No
Deebo SamuelSFO236South Carolina1/15/199626022.960.6-0.57No
Darius SlaytonNYG5171Auburn1/12/9626022.970.61-0.58Yes
Gary Jennings Jr.SEA4120West Virginia3/7/9623-0.322.820.44-0.7No
Juwann WinfreeDEN6187Colorado9/4/9617-0.822.32-0.11-0.72No
Riley RidleyCHI4126Georgia7/21/9618-0.722.440.02-0.76No
Terry GodwinCAR7237Georgia10/23/9614-1.122.19-0.27-0.85No
Anthony JohnsonTAM8279Buffalo1/29/1995330.723.921.68-0.98No
Terry McLaurinWAS376Ohio St.4/15/199615-122.710.32-1.34Yes
Hunter RenfrowOAK5149Clemson12/21/9513-
John UrsuaSEA7236Hawaii1/17/94320.624.952.83-2.23Yes

**Note: There was some bad information out there regarding Kelvin Harmon’s birthday at the time this data was put together. He’s actually a full year older, making his PI a bit meh.

Miller was unfortunately not an early declare, but with a dominant 44% of Bowling Green’s receiving yards at 21.4-years old, his 2.87 PI score wins the class going away.

Some notable results from the names atop the Index in recent years:

  • D.J. Moore, 4.64 (2018)
  • Curtis Samuel: 2.91 (2017)
  • JuJu Smith-Schuster, 2.70 (2017)
  • Tyler Boyd, 2.75 (2016, a year which had Tajae Sharpe & Pharoh Cooper atop the Index)

Miller was also the only WR in the class to break out (at least a 30% market share receiving yards) at under 20-years old. Although undersized at 5 feet 9, 174 pounds, Miller’s 4.44 forty time puts him in the 84th percentile. That, and his 16.2 YPR average as a senior hints at the kind of WR that has found success under Bruce Arians — a speedy vertical threat who can get behind the defense.

His lack of draft equity hurts the outlook, and maybe he’ll go on to be the next Tajae Sharpe, but considering the cost to acquire him in all formats, there’s no risk involved.

Justin Watson is getting a little bit of early heat at camp, but latest reports indicate he’s competing more with Chris Godwin for a role in the slot, meaning it’s unlikely he’s the one who keeps Miller off the field. Breshad Perriman is more likely to compete for an outside role, but as a first-rounder who’s not yet amassed even 1,000 total receiving yards in his four-year career, he doesn’t look like much of a threat.

It’s never a good idea to overreact to camp clips, but acrobatic catches in double coverage while playing with the first team are never a bad thing.

Playing as a rookie on a depth chart with Larry Fitzgerald, Tedd Ginn, Jaron Brown, and one-time-stud Michael Floyd, fellow undersized and under-drafted WR John Brown commanded 103 targets in Arians’ offense.

Miller absolutely has the profile to make some noise as a rookie and should probably be included in the redraft conversation.

Image Credit: Scott Grau/Icon Sportswire. Pictured: Scotty Miller.

recent and related...

in case you missed it...

NFL Week 16: Coulda, Woulda, Shoulda

Monty Phan wraps up the weekend of NFL action. For nearly four months every year, my wife puts up with a husband who is totally useless on Sundays, a slave to the Red Zone Channel and NBC Sunday Night Football. Just when the season crescendos to a climax – the

Read More

Michael Thomas Sets Records As Surprise WRs Make Their Case to Dynasty Owners

Shawn Siegele looks at all the top wide receiver performances from Week 16, including big games from Sterling Shepard, Diontae Johnson, and Steven Sims Jr. Championship weekend featured a title-winning fourth-down score from Tyler Boyd and monster performances from two legends. Michael Thomas and Julio Jones combined for 22 catches

Read More

Sign-up today for our free Premium Email subscription!

© 2019 RotoViz. All rights Reserved.